Bayesian Investor Blog

Ramblings of a somewhat libertarian stock market speculator

  • Contact Form

The Honor Code

Posted by Peter on May 1, 2011
Posted in: Book Reviews, Politics. Tagged: ethics.

Book review: The Honor Code: How Moral Revolutions Happen by Kwame Anthony Appiah.

This book argues that moral changes such as the abolition of dueling, slavery, and foot-binding are not the result of new understanding of why they are undesirable. They result from changes in how they affect the honor (or status) of the groups that have the power to create the change.

Dueling was mostly associated with a hereditary class of gentlemen, and feeling a responsibility to duel was a symbol of that status. When the nature of the upper class changed to include a much less well defined class that included successful businessmen, and society became more egalitarian, the distinction associated with demonstrating that one was a member of the hereditary elite lost enough value that the costs of dueling outweighed the prestige.

Slave-owners increasingly portrayed the labor that slaves preformed in a way that also implied the work of British manual laborers deserved low status, and rising resentment and political power of that labor class created a movement to abolish slavery.

The inability of Chinese elites to ignore the opinions of elites in other nations whose military and technological might made it hard for China to dismiss them as inferior altered the class of people whom the Chinese elites wanted respect from.

These are plausible stories, backed by a modest amount of evidence. I don’t know of any strong explanations that compete with this. But I don’t get the impression that the author tried as hard as I would like to find evidence for competing explanations. For instance, he presents some partial evidence to the effect that Britain abolished slavery at a time when slavery was increasingly profitable. But I didn’t see any consideration of the costs of keeping slaves from running away, which I expect were increasing due to improved long-distance transportation such as railroads. He lists references which might constitute authoritative support for his position, but it looks like it would be time-consuming to verify that.

Whether this book can help spark new moral revolutions is unclear, but it should make our efforts to do so more cost-effective, if only by reducing the effort put into ineffective approaches.

Posts navigation

← War and Peace and War
Too Loud, Too Bright, Too Fast, Too Tight →
  • Recent Posts

    • Evidence under Adversarial Conditions
    • Investing for a World Transformed by AI
    • BioVie
    • Investing Amid Low Expected Returns
    • Review: LOVE in a simbox
    • Cold War II
    • Blood Tests
    • What We Owe the Future
  • Recent Comments

    • Peter on Investing for a World Transformed by AI
    • Ben Smith on Investing for a World Transformed by AI
    • Peter on Investing for a World Transformed by AI
    • Sapphire Star on Investing for a World Transformed by AI
    • gwern on Investing for a World Transformed by AI
  • Tags

    aging amm autism best posts bias brain bubbles CFAR climate communication skills consciousness covid diet effective altruism empires equality ethics evolution existential risks genetics happiness history honesty industrial revolution information economics IQ kelvinism law macroeconomics meditation mind uploading MIRI neuroscience prediction markets prizes psychology rationality relationships risks seasteading status stock market crash transhumanism war willpower
  • Categories

    • Announcements [B] (6)
    • Book Reviews (268)
    • Economics (170)
      • Idea Futures (38)
      • Investing (77)
    • Life, the Universe, and Everything (143)
      • Fermi Paradox (6)
      • Health (103)
      • Humor (11)
    • Movies (2)
    • Politics (183)
      • China (15)
      • Freedom (18)
      • Mideast (14)
      • U.S. Politics (73)
    • Science and Technology (220)
      • Artificial Intelligence (58)
      • Miscellaneous (20)
      • Molecular Assemblers (Advanced Nanotech) (15)
      • The Flynn Effect (15)
      • The Human Mind (107)
      • Virtual Worlds (4)
    • Uncategorized (14)
Proudly powered by WordPress Theme: Parament by Automattic.